Well, I rate them in each category and add them up. The score is out of 50 and converts easily into how many stars I give. My personal rating system is also at the very end of the review.
The most important part of my review is the verdict section. I check off all the rules the author did not follow, I assumed all must be followed from the map submission rules. I checked again and isn't the monolith map not following the official guidelines and should be rejection if the user isn't even going to update it?