Shadow Fury

Reputation (+1):
(Post) (+1) Thanks for the feedback

Thank you for the compliments and may you be a great reviewer someday.

Yes, it will vanish. I know of you as an aspiring reviewer.

So no word from Theoden?

alright ^^

Hey there!

well.. i saw you as being really blunt.. sorry if i messed up

but do try to be bit more constructive

It is really terrible getting neg rep and to be honest, I have never got any neg rep though I committed many mistakes in the past and breaking some rules though did not receive any neg rep but an infraction which is much worse but learned from that.

Yes, I do think that you should just stay to the field that you are used to for it will be a real pain when you are reviewing something that you are not used into. I also experienced that so I know that feeling.

I hope that you are just fine there seeing you've been in some heated discussion and you got a negative reputation from Misha.

Reputation (--1):
(Post) and 'attacking' someone like a pack of wolves is not good either :/ next time let me see you being constructive in your posts

So anything else that Theoden told u about those cinem?

sorry, as I can change your rate?

/* green icons */ == rejection.
Will give you answer in next few days.

I don't think it's that long, it was around 2009-2011/2012 or so.
Wish you the best of luck, both in THW and at your Real-Life.

I do hope so, it's been quite long (about 2-4 years ago) since we have lots of active Map Reviewers.
I also hope that your suggestion can improve many maps in the future.

Glad to hear that, I am happy to see Hive have great reviewers, your talent can be a valuable asset (and might even surpasses those who have succeed in the past) to THW Map Reviewers.

It would be a good thing if you apply as an Official THW Map Reviewer by joining the Group, you can talk to -Kobas- to join the group (he will test your reviewing skill first however).

If interested, there's preview what changes I am planning to do based on your feedback in my latest post on the campaign page.

Reputation (+1):
(Post) Campaign feedback.

Nah, it's not that! I know that Theoden put you to work on some cinematics! Isn't it?

Hi there! How are today?

How ironic is it that a reviewer can't take reviews from others.

Still the 5/5 thing... Bah, it's your life.

----------
Good one. However, I feel that going directly from orange to blue doesn't give a good result. The icon that Chaosy demonstrated is what u should try to imitate. I mean, mixing both colors together might give a better result and using shading too.
----------

----------
Ur 3 icons r very similar! All share some mistakes like black background and no glows. This icon could be left like that it's tier 1 weapon, but the rest must be updated with sharper edges and glows.
If u work on this icon too, it would be better.
----------

----------
Quite cheap! Black background and nothing special! Just a light bow and arrow. Add a bright effect behind the bow like "Holy Light". Make the bow and arrow more shiny.
----------

----------
Doesn't look good to me. It looks too simple and the colors u used don't really fit together! Going from orange to a very bright color immediately gives a bad result. For now, the orange part looks great but the other two parts r not good. What to do then? Change the color of these two parts to other ones like red and yellow because they fit with orange. I know this is an elemental orb but it looks poor. Also, don't leave a black background. For each part, color the background according to the color of that part.
If u can make what I said, it'll look cool.
----------
All these clearly show that you have a very lacking sense of art, and profession in it. You'd better figure out why.

People don't criticize on you, doesn't mean you are right. Some just let it slip, but it pains my heart that you are giving misdirection.

And another thing... I don't care about your rating.. so stop mentioning about it. But you seem to fail to realize about this? The pointer you stated is much more important than the rating itself.

But that's it, I'm gonna stop here. Doubt I can ever ring your ears.

----------
UgoUgo, is it a problem if I post some suggestions on how to improve the icon? As I already said, it is awesome and very useful, but don't blame me if I say it's not perfect and that it could be improved.
----------
Suggestions are good, but you are leading people in the wrong directions.

You should post objective suggestions, not subjective. I'm sure there are few people who have already criticized the your 'strict reviews', as it is mainly based on personal taste, not on expertise and profession.

Oh and note that I'm not only referring to that 'review', but rather all of them.

Yes indeed! I like those terrains

Campaign? Interesting!

Hey man! Are you still making cinematics?

Reputation (+4):
(Post) (+4) keep getting active at the sections! Good luck!

My pleasure.

Right now.

My map is ready for dialogue correction. Thanks already.

Reputation (+2):
(Post) nice review

Change of plans! Wait for version 1.02 I'm working on cinematic skip and also difficulty system right now.

Send my e-mail ([email protected]) Make sure you correcting dialogues on lastest version.

i will inform you when time comes

i will call yoy when a cinematic comes up.

since you are a master of cinematics,would you mind helping me in my campaign?

Hehe okay cool i understand, you're welcome

Hahahah lol!

Hey, Shadow fury. Can you tell me how did you made the description in your map, Fight of mages. What BB Code is that when you click the features and it will show another messages.

Yes, and thank you. I need some help about dialogues.

great to hear. Many people do that.

Reputation (+3):
(Post) nice that you give honest reviews and not only 5/5 like most people

Hey Shadow! Will you make other cinematics too? I enjoyed Searing Conflict

It is totally fine for me if u cannot give. It's not like I am forcing you...

I gave you rep because I find it appropriate to give you because of the extremely helpful reviews and advices you can give to other mapmakers.

Reputation (+4):
(Post) (+4) Damn detailed review, nice job and here is a reward/cookie. Great job!

Reputation (+1):
(Bundle) decent job Shadow Fury

Reputation (+2):
(Post) Have another ball.