15:00, 15th Apr 2011
shiiK: Cleaning up skins that have been rejected (until updated) for more than a month - moving to rejected permanently due lack of updates since last moderation. No new review of the skin has been made. If you feel that this decission is wrong, or if you want to update the skin, please reply to this PM and I'll work it out for you. As this is a preset message, and I'm just picking up each and every skin in the category, I want to apologize beforehand if this clutters your inbox.

19:07, 11th Feb 2011
67chrome: Skins need to have 75% freehand content to be approved, and this skin falls short of that requirement. Painting over already existing material isn't entirely freehand content, as a lot of the original is showing through. I'd recommend checking out the 2D art tutorials on this site, if nothing else they have links to useful tools for skinning (and taking stellar screnshots).

Okay... dude I recommend you to remove it quikcly, before the trolls arrive

Alagremm said:

Okay... dude I recommend you to remove it quikcly, before the trolls arrive

Click to expand...

i actually like it

Its not bad, but isnt it not enough change?

i don't know if he copied the old shirt or re-did it because it has a new texture but it uses the same basic shape/color scheme

I-I-I can't tell the difference? :S
(didn't look at the blizz version yet though, might edit this post)

Trolls? where?

anyway, this really looks un-edited..

I can see the difference, though, it is hard...

Alagremm said:

Okay... dude I recommend you to remove it quikcly, before the trolls arrive

Click to expand...

I don't think it's trolling if people see this as a CnP/Re-color of the original. More of less just people giving their honest opinion whilst staying on topic about the subject itself.

Yes from the looks of it, it is just a recolor or CnP. I would recommend it stay up but removing it is the more effective idea.

To be serious, this is actually pretty well made. Its just the fact that you did not change it into anything, eg a villager with a brown shirt, purple pants etc.

Trolls... I wonder what they are talking about....

Oh my god this is EPIC!

If you want to know what's happening with the knee and exactly what part of the textures the model UVs use you can check the "WC3 Unit Wrap Compilation Project (Skin UVs)" link in my signature, it has the UVs to all the WC3 unit models.