19:07, 17th Jul 2009
zombie2279: Very damn simple, but it might be useful. I'd recommend you at least trying to detail the guy in the middle, but if nothing else, I could imagine this being better with silhouettes of an armed crowd in the background and fire behind. Or, increase the guy's size and detail him.

oh_snap: Could be useful, but I'd still would like to see more details added to the people for a higher rating.

This is maybe way too simple,
I'll probably edit it and add more stuff by tomorrow.

Army-of-Pandas said:

Review,
------------------------------------
1-Overall nice quality.
2-may need more minor details towards the person.
3-Maybe have the gun firing off?
4-Clear it up a bit when your done editing, also backround needs either another color or a highlighted glow.
------------------------------------
(All my recommendations to your icon, you can choose to use these or not, your choice.)
Thanks, Army-of-pandas.
------------------------------------------------

Click to expand...

Thank you for the review

though simple, its EPIC!

my rating: 8/10 - useful (4/5).
+2p: Overall idea is good.
+2p: Im not sure but im pretty sure that there isnt any icon like that made yet - unique!
+2p: Another modern icon. Good job!
+1p: If you think about it, it really looks like uprising.
+1p: The colours are...okay i guess.
-1p: It looks like it is about only in middle, i cant see almost anything on the sides except black.
-1p: The guy could have atleast eyes or something... (personal oppinion)

Maybe you could try replacing the glow in the background with some yellow stripes (in the same colour) which focus the image on the warrior... I hope you know what i want to suggest...

The Idea is really cool and it looks good!

Update:

Better?

Little better, but the guys on the side of the guy in the middle are quite invisible maybe place them somewhere, were we can see them. And add some detail on them as once said, also the backround seems to be fire which doesn't really go with the theme of this icon.

it's a bit to simple.. The background should show the rage.. Lige more colours instead of just the red, and the one of the persons are really only a arm. Maybe you should make him/ her more visible?

right now i will say 3/5

I like it!. Especially like the red background in the black outlines of people. I think I could go without the gun though, because if it's a Warcraft game, I don't think I saw a machine gun somewhere in the game . Ah well, looks very nice.

i like the original better D:

Looks nice. But make the glow alittle brighter right around the soldiers.

That's epic. The background is nice.

Cool Icon, I like how it features both a gun and a spear, reminds me of fallout. Perhaps brighter glow around the people, but the red glow in background suits it perfectly, perhaps make it a little brighter.

Faction said:

Cool Icon, I like how it features both a gun and a spear, reminds me of fallout. Perhaps brighter glow around the people, but the red glow in background suits it perfectly, perhaps make it a little brighter.

Click to expand...

That's a guy with an RPG behind the main guy lol

I think its perfect without being edited it just has a awesome epic mysterious feel and its very useful 8\10