Review

Notice & Contact

This map had been examined by Alexis Septimus.
If you think this map review is not accurate or require another review, feel free to contact Alexis Septimus. But, map would only be review again for second time and also for the last time unless under certain circumstances. It would be selfish to request constantly a mod/admin to keep review your map as there is many other maps waiting for approval as well.

However, if you still insist of another review after it had been review for second time. Feel free to contact other admin.

To contact Alexis Septimus, please click this

Visitor Message.

Rules Violation

Map that violates the rules of hiveworkshop could be rejected.

Below are the list of violation that could had possibly occur.

1) Map protected and never mention at detail/description/information (Map that cannot be open by ordinary World Editor must had the statement of it being protected)
2) "Just another warcraft III map" title are not allowed even if it is written at other language.
3) Blank map with nothing on it.
4) Maps with offensive map previews or profanity in the name or description.
5) Maps that are written in languages other than English without English as alternate language.
6) Map that had been approve, but deleted and re-upload to had better rating.
7) Incomplete maps/alpha stage level map are not acceptable. (Must at least be at least at late beta stage)
8) Maps that serve no real gaming function such as special effects and trigger test maps.
9) Stolen/Hack/De-protect map.
10) Maps that do not use standard keyboard characters
11) Constantly upload the same map (Different version are not acceptable as well, you should had use the update button instead.)

Other than this violation, the map could had possibly rejected under other circumstances as well.
If you fail to follow this important rule, moderators will PM you again and all future versions of your map will not be approved until you do. If any user fails to reply in some way to the PM, more serious punishments may be brought upon them at the discretion of our moderators or administrators.

Positive Review

The bottom review is the list of positive stuff about this map. Positive review usually not only about how good the map is, but also if it follow the rules of thehiveworkshop.

[√] -

Neutral Review

The bottom review is the list of suggestion/comment and opinion about the map. It usually contain an useful hint for the map author if the map author try to earn more merit point for their map.

[√] - The city terrain look quite decent and nice, perhaps you could add some weather effect for it.
[√] - The forest terrain look rather bland with just a village tree, try add a variety of destructible/doodad into it.
[√] - There is 1 thing that doesn't make sense to me, how come there is a... ugh* water flowing down towards the river from the volcano ?
[√] - The loading screen just had the map title, why don't you add some storyline about your RPG ?
[√] - You should set Medivh invulnerable.
[√] - You should set the camera view the hero once you selected it.
[√] - When a quest been discovered, accomplish or failed. There would be a game text appear about the quest, try view all those quest at warcraft 3 campaign
[√] - Instead of setting region, try set a action and condition such as owner of unit within xxx range of NPC equal to player 1 to enable the quest. Cause when I get close enough to the NPC without entering the region, the quest won't be execute.
[√] - Too many bug especially at quest log and some bug effect the gameplay. I cannot give rating 3 cause there is too many bug effect the gameplay such as making certain quest cannot be complete if you skip certain procedure.
[√] - All those quest should be optional instead of required. Required quest would make the game defeat if it failed to be accomplish.
[√] - Usually, if the hero die. The game is over especially RPG type game.

Negative Review

The bottom review is the list of negative stuff about this map. Negative review usually not only about how bad the map is, but also if it does follow the rules of thehiveworkshop or not.

[√] - Bug detected, you can had the reward from Delivery Quest without even need to bring the item to Medivh.
[√] - Bug detected, earn the reward of Delivery Quest (By using the bug mention) would make Delivery Quest could never been complete.
[√] - Bug detected, after you discovered quest. The talk to me special effect above the NPC never disappear.
[√] - Bug detected, I accomplish Deadly Rogue skill and other quest complete ?
[√] - Bug detected, I cannot attack the Bandit on top of the cliff since the hero I used is melee. The only way for me to attack him when using Demon Hunter or Paladin is by reaching level 6.

Rating & Miscellaneous information

Score - 30/100
Rating - 2/5
Condition - Average
Status - Approve
Review - 1

Reminder

The map might not be fully tested, if any user of the map found bug/error or anything else.
Feel free to contact Alexis Septimus by clicking this

Visitor Message.