15:00, 15th Apr 2011
shiiK: Cleaning up skins that have been rejected (until updated) for more than a month - moving to rejected permanently due lack of updates since last moderation. No new review of the skin has been made. If you feel that this decission is wrong, or if you want to update the skin, please reply to this PM and I'll work it out for you. As this is a preset message, and I'm just picking up each and every skin in the category, I want to apologize beforehand if this clutters your inbox.

00:36, 31st Dec 2010
67chrome: As useful as any of the three skins you submitted may be, they are all re-colors of existing blizzard work. Skins require at least 75% freehand work to be approved. If you need help improving your artistic abilities so you could create these skins with more freehand content check out the 2D art tutorials on this site

these.. all.. silvermoon skins are.. too bright and eye-tiring

You've obiously never been there =P

It'll go good with the other stuff I have planned though. Silvermoon also has a lot of white, i just haven't gotten to that part yet. SHould be easy to skin something for the dalaran building doodads.

In heinseight, i should probably make those cliff tiles white... hmmm.

FunkyDude44 said:

You've obiously never been there =P

It'll go good with the other stuff I have planned though. Silvermoon also has a lot of white, i just haven't gotten to that part yet. SHould be easy to skin something for the dalaran building doodads.

Click to expand...

I play WoW and I have been to Silvermoon, and noticed the cool a lill darker red walls, with darker gold trims and stuff

and besides, this is war3, it NEEDS to be darker, lol

I had lighting turned off, I'll update the screen with the white in a minute, it should look pretty good.

you are missing the point, every skin needs a good amount of shadows and highlights to have a good feel.

these skins... aren't good enough :/

Im sorry, but there isnt really a limit for "good enough". Theres plenty skins and models for that fact on the hive worse than this and they were still pushed through. Warcraft III doesnt detail it's skins to the extreme which gives it the Warcraft III feel. If I was trying to make it look like world of warcraft it would just be a basic CnP or took days of effort, neither of which I really feel like doing =P. Leave it up to the mods, even if it doesnt get accepted I'll still go to the forums to share it.

Wc3 also has much more definition put between the conjoining lines. Which you obviously don't have. Basically just add some darker shadows around the gold trim, and make the white have some miniscule amount of detail on it. It should look much, much better.

Looks fine to me. Not a masterpiece but useful.

Azurot said:

Wc3 also has much more definition put between the conjoining lines. Which you obviously don't have. Basically just add some darker shadows around the gold trim, and make the white have some miniscule amount of detail on it. It should look much, much better.

Click to expand...

Yeah I was looking at that. At first I thought I'd make the gold trim look closer to the wall by having a lack of, but you're absolutely right. As For saturation.... meh, yeah sure I could dink around with them. Not to say I'll like it but what the hell right?