14:54, 9th Sep 2008
Pyritie: Could be useful. Comes with standard orc death and birth anims so it fits right in with the others.

doesnt look good 2/5

looks alright... but lacks texture... looks like a few basic polygons stacked on top of eachother... has potential if redone tho

those barrs xD its just not natural ...
I sugest you make em smaller so the texture would look better and the building isn't so high. And hang some kind of carpet in front of the door opening

Looks to edgy... :S

It all looks too square and box-like, not a very good model in my opinion 1/5 because there are many more better models of orc scout towers, or models that could be used as scout towers on this site. 1/5

This is pathetic. I'm sorry but it is. All you really did was edit the orc scout tower that already exists, or so it looks. Since I feel like being nice today, I will give it a one, if it even deserves that. You might consider checking out the tutorials on modeling, they can be very useful if you are struggeling. 1/5

I agree with ray,i dont know why it was accepted,it looks like a edited tower.
1/5
Unacceptable.

IT IS an edited orc tower... cheeses ... ... ...
And i already checked them out about 1 year ago... ....
If you don't know, i have seen many models which are modification of others. Some are very good modifications, others are like mine.

Dark Hunter said:

i already checked them out about 1 year ago... ....

Click to expand...

Could have fooled me.

Dark Hunter said:

If you don't know, i have seen many models which are modification of others. Some are very good modifications, others are like mine.

Click to expand...

These models were also time worthy. All you did was reshape the tower, the "Good models" were not only reshaped, but probably recolored, with attachments of custom design added. If you can't learn from the tutorial, ask for help.

not good 3.5\5

i think i might use this. it looks bad but simple models are sometimes cool.

Sergeant Ray said:

These models were also time worthy. All you did was reshape the tower, the "Good models" were not only reshaped, but probably recolored, with attachments of custom design added. If you can't learn from the tutorial, ask for help.

Click to expand...

The tutorials aren't enough to learn. The tutorials help whit basic stuff that i know. And i made this out of boardroom, it looks exactly the way i wanted it to look. It may be simple, but i don't care if it looks the way i want it to look. Its a SENTRY tower:
http://thumb9.webshots.net/t/57/457/7/17/63/2632717630014262649FmiLfp_th.jpg
http://www.merkki.com/images/sentry tower.jpg

crap 2*

OnkelManfred said:

crap 2*

Click to expand...

Johny F. said:

doesnt look good 2/5

Click to expand...

Instead of saying, "Oh this sucks." Try giving something he might want to change. Constructive criticism instead of being a jerk.

It's alright, it just looks too boxxy. Maybe if you raised the roof a little bit it would look better. I'd give it a 3/5.

This is a pretty simple model, but it looks good. There's no point in making it look less plain if the point of the model is to look plain.
Quality of a model is not based on how "epic" it looks. I can draw an "epic" sword in 10 seconds, or I could spent 20 minutes making a high-quality image of a plain sword, to make it look exactly how I want it to look.
Although, on the side note: Icon isn't at a good angle. When making an icon, it's best to have a view from a side angle, and either below or above. You did this very slightly, but the angle needs to be increased.
I rate the model a 3/5.

if you put some windows in the tower and a ladder it will be cool
i will use this model to be my sniper tower
its a cool model --4/5--

No ladders. Use a ladder to get up, pull the ladder in with you. Why leave it down for enemies to climb?

It looks too square. Normally, that is no problem for buildings (most of which, in the real world, are vaguely square), but if you look at the Orcish buildings that ship with the game, very few of them are square. Other than the War Mill, they are all round.

Other than that, it looks okay, I guess. However, I see no reason for anyone to use it, since the Orc tower that ships with the game is much more detailed and fits in better with other Orc buildings.

hate it 1/5

Too boxy and looks simple, maybe if you give it some shape it'll look better

It's not great but it's not crap either.