CWeener's Review {Melee maps} V3.04 Review # 19

Reviewing the map "Icecrown Glacier BETA v0.1"

Rating System (in weener points:)

Rating System (in weener points:)

1-10 Replayability
1-10 Tile Variation and merging
1-10 Doodad placement
1-10 Height variation
1-10 Resource Distribution (good and wood)
1-10 Description (On THW and In-game (Loading Screen and information))
-100 or +100 for abiding by THW rules.

Rating System Scores

Rating System Scores

Less than 100 = FF- (Reported, You clearly didnt abide by all of the posting rules, and i have reported you for (not) doing so.)
100-110 Points = F- (Rancid and Needs major work. Vote for Rejection and no +rep.)
111-120 Points = F (Bad and Needs work. vote for Rejection and no +rep.)
121-130 Points = D (Below Average and Needs much updating. has potential. vote for rejection and no +rep.)
131-140 Points = C (Okay but Needs updates. has potential. vote for rejection* and no +rep.)
141-150 Points = B (Good but still not reaching full potential vote for approval but no +rep)
151-159 Points = A (Great and probably has reached full potential**. good job. vote for approval and +rep.)
160 Points = A+ (Amazing, you did everything right and went all out, approval and +rep)
_{* = depending on the map really, and what categories it scored low in
** = not always but most cases.}

Icecrown Glacier BETA v0.1

Icecrown Glacier BETA v0.1

_{Triggering scores not available, so other maximums were raised(see rating system*)}

1-10 Replayability *9* There were no MAJOR bugs or annoyances to adversely affect this.
1-10 Tile Variation and merging *10* Flawless
1-10 Doodad placement *8* Very nice, though, could have used more enviornmentals, even though ice doesn't have many >.>
1-10 Height variation *9* Very good, except some hills were just strange looking (some surrounded a gold mine?)
1-10 Resource Distribution *7* Late game gold is very low..
1-10 Description *6* Although, I understand it will be improved soon So this will change quick.
-100 or 100 Rules *100*
0-200 All-in-all *149* B (Good but still not reaching full potential vote for approval but +rep was given)

Author's Note,

A very balanced melee map, even though gold is low late game, it's okay because it's low for everybody . The tile placement was superb to say the least.
all-in-all great job, you are really close to an A, and with improvements mentioned maybe an A+

Bugs I found

Bugs:
Pathing bug for the merc camp (already known)

Recommendations

Recommendations:
Improve resources distribution (maybe 1k gold more each GM)
Fix the bug
Fix the description ASAP
Keep being awesome

Likes&Dislikes

[liked]
Well, there is simply too much to say about what I like, which is pretty much everything except the few things mentioned in [didn't like]


[didn't like]
The description,
The Doodads (or lack there of)
The bug

~~~~~~~~~~~~

If any map I've reviewed has been updated, feel free the ask me to re-review it. or if I haven't reviewed YOUR map, feel free to ask me.