15:00, 15th Apr 2011
shiiK: Cleaning up skins that have been rejected (until updated) for more than a month - moving to rejected permanently due lack of updates since last moderation. No new review of the skin has been made. If you feel that this decission is wrong, or if you want to update the skin, please reply to this PM and I'll work it out for you. As this is a preset message, and I'm just picking up each and every skin in the category, I want to apologize beforehand if this clutters your inbox.

20:23, 24th Jul 2010
Dentothor: Its good idea to start out with, but it unfortunately lacks a great amount of detail. Try to stay away from using solid colours with solid shading. It really makes the skin have a lack of texture and feeling. And this can make the skin look a whole lot more realistic and make it stand out more. Using different methods of shading for each of the few things on the skin can volumize it and give that part of the skin a feeling. For example, I cant tell the difference between the armour and the clothing. The way you shade it and texturize it, can give it a lively feeling and make it become more 3D and realistic. Which is your goal as a skinner to achieve. Id suggest looking at a few tutorials in our tutorial section. They can really help to improve your skills as a skinner and as an artist.

Finally a human archer.. Looks great.

Looks pretty good, but it needs more detail. For example put some bolts or something in those plain leg plates. And the cape could have a sign or an interesting border.

This needs shading, and more details. It looks like you've just blocked in the base colours and not done anything more.

Excellent, but I agree with people before me, it needs some details.

this could be nice, but WTF with the different colored panties?

Okay I'll update it in a few days (busy tonight/tomorrow/next day) with the ideas that people have suggested.

The loin cloth was made white as I thought that it needed something to avoid it looking bland. Would another colour be better?

well it certainly should be as the rest of those, as for other colors, i think you can add stitching or other leathery details to the boots, gauntlets and so..

the body and specially boots are way too bland atm (Boots look like a blob)

EDIT: that.. netting? on the neck could be cool on other parts that are not armor

useful and i havent seen any other human archers before but i agree with the others, a little more detail please

I think it still looks to much of an elf, just without long-ears and brightly colours.
Advice is to tune down the pale face she has. Making her, let's say, a mortal being.

When I seek to make a version that's acceptable, do I update this one or upload a new one?