11:46, 5th Aug 2009
Hawkwing: The idea is brilliant, but the quality is lacking. The face, especially. It's very blurry and the shading is rather weak.

Those hands... Hay monster?! :O.

Its a harvest golem made by a mad man!

Oh, harvest golem, now i remember D:. Good work on this one.

Lol, KelThuzad, good to see you broadening your work. =P

Of course, it's excellent being your first skin, but for an everyday skin it needs work.
Shading, shading, shading, shading, I can't stress it enough. Wait hold on. SHADING. There we go.

Everything I see here needs some intense shading, particularly:
# The face.
# Underneath the chest and stomach.
# The arms.

The "string" thing the hook is hanging froom looked weird in WC3V.
Oh and his mouth looks like a blob.

VERY nice. 5/5.
We need more of these

the face seems pretty bland, even though thats basically the exact face of the harvest watcher from WoW. i don't need to tell you it requires more shading, but I do think there might be a way to "spice" up the face/ head, whatever that is i dont know, and i dont think it'll be required to get approved, but I plan on using this in a map, so its just an idea for improvement.

add more details to the face ASAP D:

lol, the skin looks nice but the wrapped version s kinda blurry

Okay, i'm gonna be honest here: Face sucks :O
Needs a lot more detail :S