Ghostly Confusion GUI MUI v1.15 -Yixx,,-

Moderator · Feb 19, 2009

21:32, 4th Mar 2009
Hanky:

Evaluation

Rating Points

Advice: 5 points are the highest rating and 1 point is the lowest rating.

Documentation: 5
Visual Effects: 3
Triggering: 4
Idea: 4

Total:

Rating Comment

The spell is ok, there are just some small things in the triggering that are wrong like one double free and sometimes useless nullifying, but else all is fine. The spell seems to be leakless and MUI. The use of effects could be better, but it's still ok. Else all seems to be fine.

All in all a good simple spell which I just can recommend to use if you search a GUI spell like this.

Advice: If you didn't understood my rating or if you maybe have questions because you don't know how to fix bugs or leaks etc. You can always send a private message to me. I will answer as soon I got time.

Rmx · Feb 20, 2009

Well nice spell, normal simpel and good.
I like it i'll give it a 4/5

.
The tooltip is kinda confusing itself there is a mistake Confusing Them not HIM and there some other mistakes with the tooltip but that's is just fine

Need_O2 · Feb 20, 2009

too much complicated
other enemies dont spin just the one you targeted
Not so useful for anytype of map
I didnt like the idea

Rmx · Feb 20, 2009

Well ya it seem Complicated but well we are looking at a simpel spell wich isn't for any kind of map RIGHT YIXX

Yixx · Feb 20, 2009

It is a spell i made out of confusion :thumbs_up:

,,
nah, i just felt like redoing the spell,, i came up with the idea a long time ago,,
but had problems with the unit group,,
But: what do you think about the triggering?
Is it:
1) Bad, really bad
2) Could be done easier/better
3) Normal
4) Good triggering!
5) Omg! Amazing!
tell me plz ^^

EDIT:: Oh, and any bugs/leaks found??

(I know sometimes the riders walk strange, but that is nothing i can fix)
Oh, and the tooltip is fine, you confuse your enemy, but make all units around spin
So: HIM = target,, Them = Units around target, including target, that will be spinned

Wazzz · Feb 20, 2009

Hm... I think it's spectacular triggering, but I'm inclined to agree with the idea that it can't really be used for any sort of map. However, having a band of ghostly knights running through a spinning target seemed to strike a chord with me, and I love how they deal damage as they pass through. It's little op for any sort of a map (never has a Lich pwned so much

), but the trigger work is undeniably great. I'd give the trigger work a 4, keeping in mind that this spell isn't really designed for any specific map. So long as it looks good, does it really need to be for a map? And who knows, someone might find a use for it. It could make a decent Ultimate ability XD.

Kingz · Feb 20, 2009

I don't know if anyone finds this usefull, i don't...
@Rmx

Rmx said:
Well ya it seem Complicated but well we are looking at a simpel spell

A complicated simple spell o.0, lol.

Rmx · Feb 21, 2009

didn't mean it that way Kingz, i ment that it's complicated by it's SFX but not by it's trigers

Yixx · Feb 21, 2009

Does any of you guys have to say something good about the spell itself and the idea of it?
Besides that the triggering is ok, any bugs or so? I would like to know how to improve it, the effects, the triggering, you know?
Thanks for comments anyway! :grin:

-Yixx,,-

Hanky · Mar 4, 2009

Ok I checked your spell, the following:

- you leak in the trigger "GC Cast" several locations
- every group variable you use in GUI have at the begin one group, so you will leak one time a group, it's not that bad but just that you know it
- please make the demo trigger also leakfree
- you don't need to nullify integers or reals
- the effects could be done better maybe some effects above the victim that it looks confused or something

That's all for now, leave a visitor message when you fixed those points.

Yixx · Mar 4, 2009

1) Tau! Why didnt i see that?
2) I have bad experiences with Destroying Global Group variables, the three groups that are used all leak only 1 time right?
3) Done, srry for that
4) I do that to be sure they are zero and ready to be used next time the same array is used. Will that affect the score?
5) I suck at effects, but i made some effects now

Ok, ill post the visitor message =)

Hanky · Mar 4, 2009

2.) How I said it isn't that bad, but I just wanted to inform you.
4.) Abit, because for example the damage don't need to be nullified because you set it during every spell start.

Ghostly Confusion GUI MUI v1.15 -Yixx,,-

Spell Test Map (Map)

Moderator

Moderator

Rmx

Rmx

Resources

Need_O2

Need_O2

Rmx

Rmx

Resources

Yixx

Yixx

Resources

Wazzz

Wazzz

Resources

Kingz

Kingz

Resources

Rmx

Rmx

Resources

Yixx

Yixx

Resources

Hanky

Hanky

Resources

Yixx

Yixx

Resources

Hanky

Hanky

Resources

Similar threads