• 🏆 Texturing Contest #33 is OPEN! Contestants must re-texture a SD unit model found in-game (Warcraft 3 Classic), recreating the unit into a peaceful NPC version. 🔗Click here to enter!
  • It's time for the first HD Modeling Contest of 2024. Join the theme discussion for Hive's HD Modeling Contest #6! Click here to post your idea!

Eternal War v1.1

Eternal War
Created by UndeadImmortal

Map Info

Main Goldmines: 2
Expansion Goldmines: 2
Green Creep Camps: 6
Yellow Creep Camps: 3
Red Creep Camps: N/A
Goblin Laboratories: N/A
Taverns: 2
Fountain of Healths: 1
Fountain of Mana: N/A
Goblin Merchants: N/A
Marketplaces: N/A
Waygates: 4
Mercenary Camps: N/A

Media
EternalWarOverview.jpg


EternalWarScreenshot.jpg


Change Log



Added custom critters (Sting rays, and turtles).


Uploaded to hive.




Author's notes
Feedbacks are always welcome!
This is supposed to be an underwater melee map.

Keywords:
Eternal, War, EW, Eternal War, UndeadImmortal, The_Optimizer, Pony
Contents

Eternal War v1.1 (Map)

Reviews
Orcnet19:55, 28th June 2013 Map Approved Eternal War (Version 1.1) RateScorePercentLetter 5/591-100A RateScorePercentLetter 4/581-90%B RateScorePercentLetter 3/575-80%C RateScorePercentLetter 2/570-74%D RateScorePercentLetter...

Moderator

M

Moderator


1b5e5a7776e87f86f9c6951fa3dad711_64508.gif
Orcnet19:55, 28th June 2013

Comment

Review

Map Approved
Eternal War (Version 1.1)


Rate
ScorePercentLetter
addrev.gif
addrev.gif
addrev.gif
addrev.gif
addrev.gif
5/591-100A

Rate
ScorePercentLetter
addrev.gif
addrev.gif
addrev.gif
addrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif
4/581-90%B

Rate
ScorePercentLetter
addrev.gif
addrev.gif
addrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif
3/575-80%C

Rate
ScorePercentLetter
addrev.gif
addrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif
2/570-74%D

Rate
ScorePercentLetter
addrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif
1/550-69%F

Overview:

Gameplay

addrev.gif
addrev.gif
addrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif


"Game-wise its fun to play but its kinda tiny for just a melee, I like the idea of using the coatls as a different source of critters, still map is small but has sufficient use of melee mechanics."

Terrain

addrev.gif
addrev.gif
addrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif


"Terrain is decent and can be accepted in a fair rate."

Management

addrev.gif
addrev.gif
addrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif


"Totality, this map is good for 1v1 match in a tiny scale of map."

Total Score:


Rate
ScorePercentLetter
addrev.gif
addrev.gif
addrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif
th_blankrev.gif
9/1580%C
 
Level 30
Joined
Nov 29, 2012
Messages
6,637
Hey there, sorry for the late review but I would still be posting it here so here:

Good Points:

Bad Points:

Suggestions:

  • Terrain looks good though I did notice it to missed something of an animals like dolphins and fishes. And the terrain is flat, I suggest raise it a bit more but dont overdo it. Yes, you said to me on Garena that it is raised but it definetly needs more raising. And once again, trees are not fitting for an underwater themed terrain. I suggest you find one here in Hive.
  • As far as I can see, creeps are balanced enough and is not a pain in the ass.
  • Player positioning looks good
  • Map is symmetric and that is good.
Map misses a shop. I know you dont like beng suggested by adding shops but it is really needed. Item drops from creeps are not enough unless you added large amount of item drops.
  • Terrain improvements. No terrain is perfect and as we all know no one is perfect so terrain is always and will always will be open for improvements.
  • You could add some neutral shops. If you added large amount of item drops, disregard this suggestion.


Overall, this looks good for a melee map thought it misses realistic factor in terrain. Shops are just a minor thing s doesnt affect much of the rating. Rated 3/5.
 
Top