20:05, 29th Jun 2008
Werewulf: I see far too much filter work and the textures shading is far too dark and horribly done.

Recolour ?

Try changing the colour a bit; he currently looks like an ogre in a bondage suit.

It looks nice, apart from that, though.

it isn't a recolour !!! he have an armour O-o ? a recolour it's when u see a red ghoul ... and if u look a bit u see an helm with chain mail and the flag is chain mail too

ok its no recolour .. but it still looks crap .. like Ash said .. it looks like he's wearing a Bondage suit .. color the "Armor" gray /silver and add some shading .. a Black armor is hard to make ...

armor looks realy messed up, it's too dark and it doesn't looks like plate, if it is supposed to look like

2/5 armor needs more work

His head ''Chain Mail'' look friking ugly, but other wise cool: the ogre isnt a popular skin!

This is not very well made, sorry. Please work on it more.

Why is this so dark? 2/5 ATM.

beacause it's a dark ogre >:O(<---dark ogre ^^)

Positive Comments

[+] Nice colour scheme, though it dosen't really count when it's a recolour.

Negative Comments

[-] Recolour and Retone on skin.
[-] Filtered detail.
[-] Oddly placed chainmail on face.
[-] Bad style of chainmail.
[-] Poor quality armor.
[-] Ugly outline.

Comments: Mostly filters with very little freehand.

Overall Rating: 2/5

Uglyyyy

Johny F. said:

Uglyyyy

Click to expand...

That wasn't needed. Don't just say "this sucks". Give reasons; This will help them improve their work. Once you have told them what is wrong they can go back and fix these mistakes. In the future they can use what they have learned and gradually become better.

just like that i think make a bad skin himself it's better like a skin with 90% of cnp and 10% of blur ...