14:10, 28th Aug 2009
67chrome: The freehand content just looks to small for me to approve this, you need to do more with the clothing. Modifying the face a bit could look really cool to, maybe give him a 4 o' clock shadow rather than keeping the same facial hair of the original skin. You might be surprised at how much you can edit faces. Anyways, add more shading and fine-tunning to the clothing and some freehand touches to other places, such as the face

Neat. Can't say much more

EDIT: Maybe some shading?

Oooo, good idea!
4/5.

mhm its ok but does some1 realy need it?. it doesnt look so diffrent from a normal villager.

also there is more shading needet for his jacket.

Thanks for the comments. I don't think more shading on the jacket would really be visible ingame.

@ Godslayer, I needed it. Just uploading it here in case anybody else does, too.

not at all! shading = shading not = black

bah, same face as normal villager

hmm.. needs a bit more shadows and highlights

and do something about the face, so it's not default...

Looks quite good.

Looks nice, although the vest might need just a bit more shading/highlights.

first head, then everything else.

With the different lightning conditions in WC3 you need to shade the skin enough so the model will still look 3D with lighting disabled, so you definitely need to add shading. The original face dose not fit to well with this skin either, you should add more freehand work to it.

*putting my two cents in*

sweet critique Chome

67chrome said:

With the different lightning conditions in WC3 you need to shade the skin enough so the model will still look 3D with lighting disabled, so you definitely need to add shading. The original face dose not fit to well with this skin either, you should add more freehand work to it.

Click to expand...

Indeed

is this even 75% changed?

I'd say about 50%

good skin, average idea

@ Xezko, Depends on whether you count the amount changed in the actual texture or the amount in model surface covered by it...

I don't really see the need to change the face, but I'll give it a try.

You count the amount changed in the actual texture