19:32, 1st Jul 2010
Pyramidhe@d: Big image please.

5th July 2010
Pyramidhe@d: Useful.

It looks like your primary image was a nice peace of art. Sadly, the scaling really went hard on it. *sad face*

Ps. It's fun to see that you made this together with your girlfriend as well; I've always clamed that a partner would damage my relation to WarCraft, but your case seem to prove different. ;-)

Big picture

Yeah, that's nice. The hard paint-like lines are causing the trouble with pixelated rescaling, but you probably know that already. I'm no artist, but maybe someone got any useful hints at the subject; like blurring or less contrast might do it for you.

This seems blurry and undefined.

Looks pixelized, undefined. You cant make shadows or scales just with black lines.

I like

Its rather much how he resized it .. he seems to have used "pixel" resize instead of "smart size" which is in my paint shop pro program, try a different type of resizing setting instead of "pixel resize"..
see?

MUCH better as Kimberly showed it!

It's way too flat, you can't see if it's metal and why do the wings haz colored dots on it?
Sorry, but I don't think it's very useful or.. very nice.. );

Needs shadows and highlights.

Updated

You added the UPG and ATT, you didn't updated the icon itself.
Please, add some shadows and highlights.. else it might not be approved, because it's lacking..

Now that's much better. Once again, great work by you and your girlfriend. Voting for approval.

made a little improvements.

- Better shadows and highlights.
- added a glass in it.