20:53, 30th Jun 2009
zombie2279: Not bad, but it doesn't look like a buckler at all. It looks more like a mixture between a cookie and a talisman of some sort. Please, take some effort and fix the highlights, the rest is okay.

09:57, 3rd Jul 2009
zombie2279: Rejected until updated.

Nice, creative, but needs some work on the shield. 3/5 until then^^, btw. thor uses a hammer not a sword* (I think) ^^ GJ!

Review,
---------------------------------------------
1:Very bright in my part maybe dim down the brightness.
2:I dont really like the random color backround but its alright.
3:Need some dark shading on the shield.
4:Nice wooden texture on the shield.
---------------------------------------------
(All my recommendations to your icon, you can use these or not your choice)
Army-of-pandas

*Subscribing*

its creative. the color scheme is good, but the shield needs to look a bit more like a shield and not like an amulet. im liking the BG tho

Hmm, lower the background's intensity, especially to the borders. It takes to much attention away which is directly thought for the presented object.
Other than that, i agree with zombie, it's having the shape of a cookie. But that is not a huge problem since it's pretty unique, yes, but possible.
Still, the material the buckler is made of needs more characteristic texturing, then comes the proper highlightning.
Generally quite creative and interesting.
Just keep making icons.