01:54, 16th Oct 2009
enjoy: Looks good. Can be usefull.

The icon itself looks awsome, but I really don't get what it is, and the idea is bleh tbh.

But it looks awsome

really epic icon, but i needed some time to get what it is.

Oh ok. ill try to explain it on update

I really like it. The hand looks nothing like a hand though, and the glaive is way thinner than the Wardens.

the hand is the sharp points from the wardens gauntlet

Fair enough, but should it be placed that low? If you look at the circular form, the gauntlet spikes have to be really long.

that would be my failure with perspective

This is awesome. It doesn't really look like the weapon's being sharpened to me, though. It looks like it's shooting out some magic.

This is amazing, once again.
You are a genius.

This looks really beautiful, but I would like to see some more of the weapon.

This is awesome as allways. Good job! 5/5

Love the idea !

Lolz at first i was seeing an awesome circular wooden weapon with blades on the edge being sharpened, and it looked real good.

Now that i know this is suppsoed to be the warden's weapon, i think there are 2 errors:
-It looked wooden because there is no metal circle in your weapon, and the bright purple from the sharpening process has a weird direction.

The real warden's weapon looks more like a metal circle with blades "attached", while yours only has the blades, that seem to be attached to each other, or to that thread-thin sorta golden circle that we can see. If that's supposed to be the metal circle i've been mentioning, it needs to be much wider, as in, more like a wheel, if you know what i mean.

Too much blade for not enough thickness, put short. Here is a pic where you can easily see the difference:
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/_bRjwsxSqWM8/SHvxMzHwcDI/AAAAAAAAAEY/PCfyBFjJBAs/s400/war3x-warden.jpg

The other problem is the direction of the purp light coming from the stone, all rays go in the same direction, while since it's light, it should go in all directions.
->The fact that it's the way it is in your icon, makes it look like something else than light. Makes it look like the inside of the weapon is wooden. Look to the left of the icon, there are rays of light coming from nowhere, or at least, not from the sparkle caused by the sharpening. Or maybe that's just me.

Overall, colors and details look great though.

ok.. hmm i rly like the colors but i dont think i would take it in a map just cuz i rly dont understand it >.< i wouldnt like people to do like... ''Wtf is this weapon'' when they play... maybe zoom out a lil and make it more possible to understnad

i appreciate the feedback but i dont really want to edit the icon because i lost the psd file when my hd died. i was able to save the png file of the icon from when i sent it to Sominium.(made this icon few months ago) Maybe i shall remake it someday

Ah, that's too bad.

And don't get me wrong, the icon is lovely, only it could've been slightly better. Oh well *shrugs*.