Useful, but lacking in quality. I recommend complete reworking. Try to put the blade into a better perspective to give room for more and better details.

It looks quite undefined and blurry. It doesn't have the same standard as those you use to do.

lol yeah i noticed it took me like 5 min. im improving it now

Lets start: The blade and handle are obviously deformed relative to each other, so you need to straighten. The handle is also a little bent and the edge of the blades(all three) is a little crooked. The blade needs more metallic reflection or it looks like clay. And the boundary between blade and handle is not too well done, it looks like the handle is eating into the blade so try and seperate them with a clear and defined edge. Also, add highlights to fill up the icon or it looks too bland. A blue or green glow around the sai would make it look a lot better.
At present, i dont think this is suitable quality for approval. When making icons, don't rush man, take your time.

duh i know that... i know what i need to fix and it is all being done as we speak as said in the previous post. please read the post before commenting dryly on my icon

Yeah sorry. Won't happen again for 5 months.

Updated

Comment and critisize!

Looks a whole lot better. The blade still needs some metallish highlight elements added.

I simply need to say this as a last review. Blade needs metallic shading, and you also need to straighten the handle and blade so they fit with one another cause if you look carefully they're bent. And the prong on the bottom is deformed and doesnt match the one on the top. Add glow. Then it'll be complete.