14:48, 12th Sep 2010
Pyramidhe@d: Useful

attaching rest of the icons..

Then provide a new PSD. file with no merged layers.

i'll hope this is good enough

More shiny! That yellow/gold color looks kind of lame

Did you copy one star and make 4 of them, then place them and make only one gold?

It looks, Alright, but i agree with Elainel, more shiny, That star kinda looks dull, But good effort. 4/5 +Rep.

Elainiel said:

More shiny! That yellow/gold color looks kind of lame

Click to expand...

That.

Scroll down too the last rank, did you CnP this? grggwg

Army-of-Pandas said:

Scroll down too the last rank, did you CnP this? grggwg

Click to expand...

That does look like he has, they are almost Exact. Except his is yellow.

xDeathKnightx said:

That does look like he has, they are almost Exact. Except his is yellow.

Click to expand...

Yes the only free hand type part is the yellow.

Army, he submitted it a second time because he did it "freehand". I already provided proof that he CnP, and recolored the first one. And this one is only altered a bit differently.

~Snap

Insufficient stars

oh_snap said:

Army, he submitted it a second time because he did it "freehand". I already provided proof that he CnP, and recolored the first one. And this one is only altered a bit differently.

~Snap

Click to expand...

I know what i did and that was to freehandedly paint 1 star and then copy it 4 times, i was told it''s against the rules so now i drawn them all one by one and uploaded this.
I'm not trying to be an ass just dont want people to believe whats not true about me

Crave. said:

Insufficient stars

Click to expand...

you mean there are not enough stars or are they lacking in quality?

I mean i see what your saying but by looking at the stars closely i dont see much difference between them. As you did say that you re-drew all of them, im just wondering is all.

This wasn't CnP, look at the shadow, its sloppy, unlike the link. Plus the link has a shadow on the bottom. This has a shadow on the top.

The link has nothing to do with it, i said that because you cant copy the star 4 times and paste it, you have to re-draw it in-order too get the full free-hand percentage in the icon.

xDeathKnightx said:

That does look like he has, they are almost Exact. Except his is yellow.

Click to expand...

If it wouldn't be almost exact then the stars would be a failure, they HAVE to look like those.

BTW, i don't believe this is a CnP, but yes i think it needs more shading and highlights, aren't they metal stars?