08:54, 5th Aug 2009
zombie2279: Great work.

posting to subscribe.

Omigawd. Epic.

Looks cool but u can only see a few part of the Blade :/
Is it 100% selfmade?

yep. Well, Ill post the sketch if there´s any doubt. Hold on a moment...
And btw, Im not stupd enough to CnP :3

EDIT:


The update will apply pretty soon...

It's pretty nice, but the incredibly dark shading on the edges of the crossbar makes it seem like outlines. And when the rest doesn't have any outlines, it looks a bit... Well... Funny.

Well, that's my opinion anyways. But it's still a pretty nice icon. 3.5/5 :]

Kinda... Boxy?

that should be fixed in the new update. If it wanna apply anytime soon :/
Both of those, lol.

EDIT: its updated.
though I figured none of your comments had nothing to do
with that... oh well... anyway,
its boxy, yeah.
what can I say? D:

not bad, but i think there have been too many sword icons lately...

which is of course no reason to not approve this.

another thing i'd like to mention is that the sword as a whole looks a bit strange because the blade fades away into the background while the (german 'parierstange' the thing above the handle ^^) comes too much into the foreground.

you should think about adding some more outlines as well.
and think about the light source. i comes from the left, right? the right side of the blade isnt darker than the left though.

thats it for now.

VERY nice, 5/5 +rep.

honestly it looks more like a tool than a sword. what is the pixel size of the full pic? the 64x64 has jagged lines

Work on the shading and highlighting of the blade, as Palaslayer suggested, and this icon should turn out wonderfully.

just noticed that blade shading thing.
And yeah, I know it's been too many sword icons, but well, I wanted to try as well :3

looks gr8, just looks like alot of boxes though 4/5

Fix the handle.

a little more specific..?

Well, as you see the handle looks like a bottom of a screw if you see. As of the changing i would say too smooth the edges of the handle down so it looks straight and smooth. Then, add details and effects as a handle would look like.

Theres white gaps between everything! It looks like this sword can be pulled apart and put together again like lego.

great work indeed

Omg looks crazy

crazy means good or bad? o:
I cant really know what to think now when Aop and ex turned into morons and blames me for everything I do.

I'm glad you idiots chose me as the one to pick on, because I'm pretty used to it.
The only different being I cant kick your asses over the net.

good, real good.

Mobilize? I just said the handle looks like a screw.

very nice
5/5