21:21, 8th Jun 2011
Pyramidhe@d: Completely flat. No shading at all.

23 June 2011
Pyramidhe@d: No changes made

Not so bad at all! 4/5 for your work... +REP

*EDIT*
I forgot that i'm a very new member so i can not rate yet. But if i could I would rate you 4/5

If you have a square jar at home, try to copy the glassy texture and the effect it has with objects in it.

Thanx

This is Bigger but blurry because resized it after i uploaded it

Looks promising, with some highlights I'll rate it =)

Well the liquid inside is just red color... no shading, this looks pretty ugly now, actually.
At the current state the icon will definetly get rejected, but shading it to look more realistic might save the situation.

it's alright i think... you should move the potion more on the middle, use some shading and colour variety. some kind of bg wouldn't hurt either x) U got lotsa to improve! gl

Its rather plain and flat.. simple yet nice.. but not enough.. shading and better detail and focus will be loved.. at this moment, its hard to see the glass it self.. but other than that, its quiet promising

- Liquid inside is just red color
- Not higlights
- Not glass effect
- Icon its too empty/black

Ohhhh

Well you should definetly try and immprove the icon if you want it to get approved...

Ok i will improve my icon}