15:51, 12th Sep 2009
oh_snap: Rename the icon to a proper name, to start off. And the background looks quite messy, fix those.

Zombie: It is random, unuseful, not well made and I don't see anything more than a practice of some sort. Even the brushes are visible.

Rejected.

the name fits the icon PERFECTLY.
because all i see is a giant mesh of random colours.

Looks like goop =/ But what does goop look like... Curious. But seriously, what is it supposed to be?

Well wow. I think it looks amazing. It could be a pearl or something.

More shading on the lower parts of the orb could make this icon a decent quality. Also, it's a good idea to not use white as a background, as it tends to divert the eye's attention away from the main object, whereas black is seen as empty space and pushes the viewer's attention towards the main object.

Make the overall icon look sharp instead of messy as it is, and maybe add some more effects.

Could be useful... although I don't see it special...