21:44, 20th Jan 2016
Sin'dorei300: Nicely done!

Master, earlyWIP, feather layer and background layer.

Nice attempt at making a "freehand" icon.

Why's the hand blurred? Can you sharpen it a little bit? Otherwise, This icon is just outstanding.

Kick in the shins, this icon.

Roland said:

Why's the hand blurred? Can you sharpen it a little bit? Otherwise, This icon is just outstanding.

Click to expand...

It's only blurry in the full size image, the icon is fairly sharp. I didn't want to use any tools except brushes, so that's as sharp as I could get it. I suppose if I made the original at 512x512 it may have been better, but for a 64x64 icon, that seems like overkill.

Apheraz Lucent said:

Kick in the shins, this icon.

Click to expand...

It's not meant to be towards you, but Sin' didn't like my use of the circle and square tools so I went all brush. I know there is a touch of sarcasm in it, but I honestly hope he likes it and I definitely learned something from limiting myself to just brushes. If it was not for being pushed, none of us would improve, so I am actually grateful for that. However, if he feels it in the shins just a little, that's ok with me too.

What do you think of the icon?

You can some blue cloth to the hand. It makes it more elegant. Something like James Cook

I myself got a little bit different approach to freehand definition.

But, the icon looks very realistic. Maybe a bit too much for Warcraft. Very nice job on shading tho.

Great work as always!

I'm sure Sin'dorei300 will like this since he is a fan of freehand icons xD
The icon itself seems decent,except the hand is blurry and needs some defining

WhiteFang said:

I'm sure Sin'dorei300 will like this since he is a fan of freehand icons xD
The icon itself seems decent,except the hand is blurry and needs some defining

Click to expand...

Now, sharpen it up a bit(in the small size).

Legal_Ease said:

I'll see what I can do. I'm not really sure how that's done, but I have some ideas. Any suggestions? I saved the layers separately this time.

Click to expand...

Something like this should be fine.

As for your question: just Merge all your layers(with whatever option your software has) and then resize the image to 64x64.
After that just use a Sharpen option from your software.

Then Save As a separate tga/which format you want to avoid saving the changes to your Layered image.

Note: I use Photoshop.

Heinvers said:

Something like this should be fine.

As for your question: just Merge all your layers(with whatever option your software has) and then resize the image to 64x64.
After that just use a Sharpen option from your software.

Then Save As a separate tga/which format you want to avoid saving the changes to your Layered image.

Note: I use Photoshop.

Click to expand...

I use pixlr.com.

Here's what I was able to come up with:

Few of the quickest approvals..
Deserved!

Love this!

I find it great, but what if the paper was brown color like the old paper and the blue fading was more shading and dark

Warseeker said:

I find it great, but what if the paper was brown color like the old paper and the blue fading was more shading and dark

Click to expand...

Yup, that probably would look better.

Beautiful.