19:44, 12th Sep 2008
Kimberly: simple recolours are not allowed.

Well this would be my second icon
So what you guys think?

i think u can make it more vivid (the fire and add some orange to the hand)

At the moment it doesn't look too much like fire, the part below the hand is too... peachy.

Add more colour to it, right now it's a good concept and very useful, especially since you made ATC and PAS.

Would something like this be better?

I updated this, but why the icon pictures doesn't change?
EDIT: Oh ... Had to wait moment :O

That's much better, 5/5, very useful and vivid.

5/5 just brilliant

I was thinking that it would cooler if the flames didn't outline the hand, they just kind of engulfed it. If that were the case it would look kind of like a guy completely drenched in flame reaching out of the flames. Totally badass.

I don't think that's the aim of the icon though.

shamanyouranus said:

I was thinking that it would cooler if the flames didn't outline the hand, they just kind of engulfed it. If that were the case it would look kind of like a guy completely drenched in flame reaching out of the flames. Totally badass.

Click to expand...

I had that idea while I was making this icon, but decided to go with the current look

Yes but it would look badass, even if it wasn't meant for that, I think it would look batter like that because fire doesn't really conform to the shape of something, it just goes in one direction and goes over whatever is in the way. Just a thought.

Well, ok, its your icon. I'm not gonna make you do it.

shamanyouranus said:

Well, ok, its your icon. I'm not gonna make you do it.

Click to expand...

Not like you even had the power to make me do so xD

Oh yeah I do.


You WILL change the icon!

shamanyouranus said:

Oh yeah I do.

You WILL change the icon!

Click to expand...

I think you gonna need to use your ''big and mighty'' hypnotic skill

Hmm, immune to jedi mind tricks I see.

I'll have bring in the aid of:

OBI WAN GINOBILI!!!

^HEY U FOLLOW MY DEVICES jeje thx..it seems very good know hey can u see my megamorph new one i wait u like it^^ and that this time it will not be rejected

Too much recolour. Simple as that.

I can only see the hand is recolor for farie fire, what the rest?

Hawkwing said:

Too much recolour. Simple as that.

Click to expand...

So? I see no point why not to approve, cause even this is approved BTNPoisonArrows - The Hive Workshop - A Warcraft III Modding Site

The Rules said:

Freehand Content
All icons must be at least 50% freehand created. Non-freehand techniques include mirroring, cloning (or brute cloning, as in clear copy-paste), recoloring, resizing, and rotating.

Click to expand...

Good point. But I suppose there could still be some more freehand.

no he is certain my icons was some recolor and freehand and didn't get aproved..however is not the page supposed to give users art solutions?? my avatar is one of my icons u can see my in icon section and leave comments.


ALso thx for follow my device i wait this one be approved is a very good icon..and there is enough free hand to be aproved dont u see the poison arrows are full of free hand and are very well made ò_0

X.e.r.e.X said:

So? I see no point why not to approve, cause even this is approved BTNPoisonArrows - The Hive Workshop - A Warcraft III Modding Site

Click to expand...

X.e.r.e.X that icon is four years old, much can have happend since, also changes in the rules.

yes but still is being a very good point

A pure recolour isn't exactly.. acceptable. Like I said, add SOME freehand. Anyone can make a recolour.

the rules have changed, the hive was jong and lonely, it needed rescources back then.
Now the hive doesnt take rcolors anymore. This needs more freehand!

in first place may be the hive doesn't need it but the users do..thats is why it is a good point..however u wanna see free hand u will see it from me

This seems to have 50% freehand to me. It looks pretty good, but the color still could be a bit more orange 4/5.