01:07, 9th Mar 2015
enjoy: This icon looks really nice, I just want you to add a little more contrast to it. Other than that, it's great.

16:44, 21st Mar 2015
Sin'dorei300: No changes made.
Awaiting update.

15:21, 28th May 2016
Sin'dorei300: Some changes were made, but you could still tinker with its contrast a bit.

good start, needs more contrast. a back light tho unnecessary wudn't hurt, and wud add a blizzard feeling

Neat icon. Good job for your first icon. 3/5!

A really interesting, well-made, ( for me) unseen icon.

Although, I don't like that you try to make other users pity you when reading your description. Just don't do that. Most Users will criticize you on a professional, artistically level and they surely don't want to hurt you, even if they have a bad day.

I would have one suggestion: Improve shading.
It is already well-made and correctly placed, but you could add a stronger, darker shadow under the cloth, as there is no light source and the light comes from the right-hand site top.

A very good first icon

the previous persons already said everything of my mind

3.5/5, gave 3.

Very nice. I see nothing wrong with it.

The main problem seems to be the lack of stronger proper highlights on the material.

I like anyway

Smooth as fuck, but I'd probably do the suggestions of the users above

It is too soft, too smooth, etc. What else would we expect from fabric?

To me it is delicate as it should be. A nicely done icon, really. You say we're free to steal the credit, well, I would gladly do that

And this - also for the Commodities system!