17:29, 2nd Oct 2015
Sin'dorei300: The best icon of ur set.
I approve this icon, without rating.
I'll add the rating after u have improved it.

The fiery part isn't defined well and it feels cartoonish. I think the background isn't done properly also, probably because the contrast between the orange background and the light yellow of the rifle's burst doesn't look fancy. Other than that, the icon looks great. I like the way you did the rifle but probably you should add some lighting effects on its tip to make it more realistic (burst effect of rifle causes a flash).
Looking forward to seeing improvements

Looks a bit like a party popper; needs some more definition/contrast. Basically what Shadow Fury has said.

Noice.

I've been looking for this! Nice Job!

5/5

The best icon of ur set. Though, it needs some small improvements.
That fire is okay, but the gun needs more shading, looks kinda flat atm.
The contest's judges have already pointed out some flaws. So, i advise u to improve this icon considering the judges' observations too.

Compliments the default Long Rifles and Black/Refined/Imbued Gunpowder Icons. Can be used an alternative spell/upgrade along side. The different coloring and shading make it stick out while blending well with all the other Warcraft themed icons. 3/5