10:06, 19th Jul 2009
zombie2279: Zoom out, so one can actually see it's an axe and give it some more metallish highlights. It's not bad nevertheless.

20:00, 30th Jul 2009
zombie2279: No changes made, but it's approvable with the overall randomness discounted.

cant quite tell what it is.

if you zoom out, we may can see what it is. for now, I cannot tell you what it is

well. this looks really good. gimme the psd or something else plz.

It kinda looks like a sword with axeblades attached to it Oo

Anyway good job

hmm. .weird .. but nice 4/5

really doesnt look axe-like
but still cool icon 4/5

The concept generally doesnt surprise but is well executed in a clear manner.
But you have to weaken the background.

Shadings are okay, the top right part of the object could need some touch ups in those, but such detail is optional.

Looks ok, but not like Axe.

Not gonna do a review.

Just zoom out and it'll be good.