Approved
Moderator
M
Moderator
21:13, 30th Oct 2009
enjoy: I will take a guess and say that this is your first icon. It's bad, but don't worry, cause I have seen much worse. You got the placement of the shading and highlights right, but blend it out. Also needs more shading and more highlights. You should also try to improve the shape of it. A cupcake isn't really that useful though.. Try to make something else, like a sword. Take a look in the tutorial section, There is a icon tutorial by CRAZYRUSSIAN. I am sure you will find it very useful
I will have to reject this, since it doesn't forfill the standarts, but I look forward to see improvements.
enjoy: I will take a guess and say that this is your first icon. It's bad, but don't worry, cause I have seen much worse. You got the placement of the shading and highlights right, but blend it out. Also needs more shading and more highlights. You should also try to improve the shape of it. A cupcake isn't really that useful though.. Try to make something else, like a sword. Take a look in the tutorial section, There is a icon tutorial by CRAZYRUSSIAN. I am sure you will find it very useful
I will have to reject this, since it doesn't forfill the standarts, but I look forward to see improvements. 
