08:47, 2nd Aug 2009
oh_snap: Looks great, the only issue I see is that the sword is not distinct from the background. Fix that minor issue, and I'll approve it.

oh_snap: Looks wonderful, Recommended.

Woah, nice icon, looks quite useful, might be useful as a item weapon. Soft and beautiful in a way of perspective.

Rating: 4.85 /5 (I will test it first for my real rating.)
P.S. You may want to stand out the sword out better; however the soft texture appeals me however.

needs more contrast/shading. can't really see the details

Looks good, but handle and color variation needs some work. Hmm, make the handle a different color as a handle would have not the same color as the blade part as it mixes together. Also, maybe brighten up the blueish middle part on the sword it is quite hard to see from the lightness of the color at the moment.

needs more shading on the sword metal part, other than that! its EPIC!
nice Akon! i mean icon! lulz

Looks pretty cool. But i dont know why it looks a little cartoonish.

nice
4.0099999/5

The improvements look phenomenal. Good job.

the updated version is more EPIC now!

Whoa. That's nice!

Woah, changes now. I like it, might use it for my game (I will credit you ). Keep you the good work, you have my vote. I will raise my voting from 4.85 to 4.95 / 5, some good changes after a long day.

Bloody hell! thats beautiful!
5/5 +rep.
i like the creepiness in this one!