11:07, 3rd Jan 2009
Paladon: I recommend you to increase the size of the key, since this could be an item-icon. Else the key might appear needless. That´s why i only rate "Useful" currently.

It seems fine but the thing I don't like is that I got the feeling, if I actualy took the key in my hand, it would dissolve. Looks like its made of water. Yes, I read the title, maybe this was the idea, however I don't like that. The background looks good. Maybe you should center the key on the middle? Dunno, I'm not so good a icon reviewer. I would give this a 3/5. It looks good, but still lacks a bit, but as I said I'm not so good as a icon reviewer

If i were you, i'd go for a classical key shape here.

looks more like a ghost key

it looks better without the key