22:25, 8th Jul 2009
zombie2279: The overall shape is a bit weird, and it does not exactly look like a sharp blade, it looks more like a blunt weapon of some sort. The highlights and shadings are actually quite overdone now, use some more colour tones to shade instead of using straight-out black.

8:47, 12th Jul 2009
zombie2279: Rejected until updated.

This looks horrible when uploaded ><

EVERYBODY! DOWNLOAD AND CHECK IT FOR REAL!

don't get me wrong but.

it looks like a yellow __.

forget it.



the sword isn't really glowing however, and the teal makes no sense.

too colorful IMO

It had tons of definition in the full picture >.=.<

Then, of course, I scaled it down and it Failed D:

are you working at 128x128?

This Icon is pretty bad, but ingame just totally changed my mind!

err, the backround makes it awful,looks grindy, but. .
still a useful and a nice icon!
4/5

This looks pretty good, it fits the style. But, add more swing effect.

Gotcha.

could you add the 128x128 version ? or wips?

I'll post up the 256x256.

i think the problem is the handle.

or the overall "Blunt" look.

and it's not exactly straight.

the texture of the blade looks kinda like wood