15:00, 15th Apr 2011
shiiK: Cleaning up skins that have been rejected (until updated) for more than a month - moving to rejected permanently due lack of updates since last moderation. No new review of the skin has been made. If you feel that this decission is wrong, or if you want to update the skin, please reply to this PM and I'll work it out for you. As this is a preset message, and I'm just picking up each and every skin in the category, I want to apologize beforehand if this clutters your inbox.

09:37, May 17 2010
Dentothor: Dude... there is almost nothing changed other than a drastic increase in filesize, and the Name. The chainmail din't need to be darkened. it needed to be either removed or had a total change in concept.

The rest of the skin lacks in a lot of body shading and looks totally flat. I would suggest reading about lighting and shading to improve your skills in this area. Mr.Goblin's Tutorial is a good tutorial to go by to improve shading and detail skills, that of which this skin desperatley needs. Rejected until updated.

I think it is ok
for me it looks ok (maybe need some shading at the body but i'm a noob at skinning ^^)

Awesome thank you very much bro! +rep
EDIT:Btw there is little white on the shoulders ?

The chain mail is too stark compared to the rest of the skin.

The chainmail looks odd to me for some reason. Also, the belt looks just like flat paint.

I can see, that you quite put some effort into it, but I can hardly see boromir in this skin, for me it's just a random villager, especially because boromir has darker hair.
Also the skin needs more shading to look good in wc3, especially the belt!

Keep it up!

You'd need a different style of texturing on this one..

chainmail is.. it doesn't even look like one..

boromir had brown hair iirc

Ghost765 said:

boromir had brown hair iirc

Click to expand...

ok i got lots of complains about the hair being darker and i will fix it no prob. And aboyt the cainmail i will work on that too

If you want you can look at the chainmail of my DK skin, and i love this skin, hope to see this improve!!

Ampharos_222 said:

If you want you can look at the chainmail of my DK skin,

Click to expand...

Why not just use the chainmail tutorial...?

Ehh, could be improved so much...

Pretty good in my opinion. :/
The chainmail actually looks decent ingame.
(and isn't that where we should be looking?)

hmmm i think its nice but it doesnt look like boromir and the chains need LOTS of work

ThE ChAiNs look weird

I think you should make the rings on his chainmail smaller. They look quite large.

hmm... if by chance you want to keep this ring-mail.. then i suggest you do the shadings highlights and folds of the regular cloth underneath the rings.. as it looks rather bland now...

the chain mail hole was big to each others! looks like the leg and arm so many hole! make it a change