Vengeancekael: Private Message
Date: 2011/Dec/10 23:43:21

Reasons:
Poor and lacking terrain: Terrain Tutorial

Other:
Check out the tutorials section: Tutorials
Check out the Map Development Section: Map Development Section
Check out the World Editor Help Zone (Trigger issues, object editor, overall WE issues): WE Help Zone
Comment: It's an acceptable melee map, although lacks some kind of originality or new strategy points, but the layout doesn't actually look like a banana in any way. Another thing would be the emptiness of the environment, add more plants, even in the water. (at the cliff edges)
Also, bonus goldmines would be nice.
Admin Contact - Resource Moderation - Rules

edit: Updated and approved.

Why is it called Banana Island? D:

Cause i was eating banana while making it.

The whole time?

It's an acceptable melee map, although lacks some kind of originality or new strategy points, but the layout doesn't actually look like a banana in any way. Another thing would be the emptiness of the environment, add more plants, even in the water. (at the cliff edges)
Also, bonus goldmines would be nice.

Rejected until updated.

well.. to me it looks like someone tried to create shallow water and failed..

but the map looks decent

Actually, it doesn't look THAT terrible, bit small though don't you think? Make moar hostiles, and maybe a special addition to a common melee map.
Overall:
Terrain: 2.5/5
Idea: --
Units: --
Balance: --
Triggers: --
Average: 2.5/5

It Doesnt look like banana and you eat banana until you finish making the map ??

offtopic: rofl you just gave me an idea, ill make a TD while eating an apple and ill name it Apple TD xD

ontopic: well your map is good but nothing special...

Wut the heckzor is wrung with the map being named ''banana island''? It just perfectly fits in this jungle themed ''cross the odd word out'':
Palm, banana, broiler, monkey
Yes, broiler

Misha said:

well.. to me it looks like someone tried to create shallow water and failed..

but the map looks decent

Click to expand...

By ''decent'' u mean ''clean of terrain features''? ;DD
Yeah, that - it leaks

haven't found any banana...
and terrain is... not good i think...

This can be approved with minimal rating

Terrain is bad, but there is enough room for build, and main problems are fixed/evaded.
I don't like item drops, make them completely random and you will score bonus
Oh add some tile variation and increase build size near expansion gold mines

2/5