Approved
Moderator
M
Moderator
19:01, 15th Mar 2014
Orcnet:
Orcnet:
eubz;2498300 said:This is such a promissing melee map. And having a low file size is a plus. Judging from the mini-map I could already tell that this is a balanced map. IDK for other things so downloading... for the review.
Map Reviewer: eubz
Map Name: Autumnwoods
Map Author: Super Jakiro
Map Uploader: Super Jakiro
Originality
As an overall impression, This map is just another Altered Melee map with few things being changed. What should be done is to add a new race. This map just used default races I guess.
Score: 28/100
Critical Error -> Vote for Rejection!
Presentation
You have your map informations presented. The features and change logs are also presented including all the necessary persons to give credits to. One thing is that you just need to polish it using some bb codes.
Score: 10/100
Critical Error -> Vote for Rejection!
Design
Map design is cool. As I said, it is very much symmetrical and has a potential.
Score: 49/100
Terrain
I like the terrain, it is too balanced but the trees and the land textures are contrasting. The doodads are well placed and neutral units, too.
Score: 58/100
Triggers
I have nothing to say about the triggers because it uses the Default melee game initialization for all players.
Score: 51/100
Object Data
I am not much pleased because many of the units and heroes used the default models while you just change some properties of others. Good that you have imported stuff, though.
Score: 41/100
Gameplay
During the game, since this is an altered melee map, I am thinking that a new race will emerge but sadly, no new race has come out. Instead, each race has a unit replacements just like footmen replaced by soldiers and some other changes on basic races has been done, too. During the game, since this is an altered melee map, I am thinking that a new race will emerge but sadly, no new race has come out. Instead, each race has a unit replacements just like footmen replaced by soldiers and some other changes on basic races has been done, too.
Score: 13/100
Critical Error -> Vote for Rejection!
MORE SUGGESTIONS:
1. If you can create a new race that'll be better.
2. You can either change the type of trees to use or change the land textures to fit with the trees.
3. Fix your description.
Map still in development? Make a thread in the Map Development Section for feedback.
Need help with triggers/memory leaks? Make a thread in the Triggers & Scripts Section.
Tutorials
Final Score: 35.714/100
1/5 Vote for Rejection
Contact: (Visitor Message) / (Private Message) / (Map Reviewers)
