20:49, 30th Jul 2008
Rui: According to the reviews I see below, the map can be approved.

Just played it, here's my review for the dbz race:
But first, change the WarCraft Maul Remade in the Leaderboard if you want to make it look more authentic.
First thing i noticed was kuririn having a -50% hp-attack.
Now, what about spamming kuririns all over (they're cheap) and put a damagetower with splash (almost all of them have it) at the end to get rid of all problems.
I had the same problem with my map (Lich @ undead) and i made a chance-to-splash out of it. Think of a solution
It also would be great if the host could decide the difficulty.
The customs are pretty well made (although i don't like them), no cons on this.

Last, the balancing (yeah ^^): Genkidama 20k dmg - WTF? Also think of editing the tooltips so one can look for the damage caused by e.g. piccolo's ships (wtf?).

The map needs work (as all mauls need) and it won't be easy but whatever people say about mauls, remember that if you mod it you think (i hope so) you can increase a maul's quality with your thoughts and also people will approve that. If you like me to, i could offer help
Also the annoying antistucktowers have to be replaced with the well-known prod ability

~> 2/5

I love this maul ! but kakashi is very to strong.

Just wanted to make a few things clear.

I will be the first person to admit that the last version I uploaded on here (v0.90) was extremely bugged, laggy and unbalanced. Heck, some towers were missing and there were a few crash bugs.

However, after that and getting a few bad reviews, I decided not to upload onto HW again until I felt the map was in a good enough state so that I felt proud of it (There are several versions I uploaded on Epic War that I did not upload here). That time is now. While there might be a few imbalanced towers here and there that I have missed, balance is FAR improved compared to the last version.

Therefore I hope people will not judge too much on the old comments and scores. Also, thanks for your post Squiggy, helped me with balance and gave me a few ideas.

@LinkinFull
Thanks for giving me the heads up on Kakashi, that had not come through in my Beta Testing. I will be submitting v0.952 in about an hour since I forgot to list a person in my credits, and I will balance Kakashi in that too.

Map Review

Map Reviewer Nanoha-

Ok Frist thing i wanna say Great map and well done, So this will be mostly postive comments cause i didnt find much wrong.

{Over View}
[+2] As any maul good Balanceing.
[+2] Many Towers, Along with Models (Such as Bleach)
[-1] For Slow and not very good comps This can cause some lag, But not to much.
[0] Terrain is plain BUT all mauls are alike so i will not take points off.
[0] Is playable and dosent seem to be Riped off are Stolen.

Over all
5/5 For a Nice Fun and Easy game!

Good job with this map!

Well this will most likely be approved, and keep up the good work!

Nanoha- said:

Map Reviewer Nanoha-

Ok Frist thing i wanna say Great map and well done, So this will be mostly postive comments cause i didnt find much wrong.

{Over View}
[+2] As any maul good Balanceing.
[+2] Many Towers, Along with Models (Such as Bleach)
[-1] For Slow and not very good comps This can cause some lag, But not to much.
[0] Terrain is plain BUT all mauls are alike so i will not take points off.
[0] Is playable and dosent seem to be Riped off are Stolen.

Over all
5/5 For a Nice Fun and Easy game!

Good job with this map!

Well this will most likely be approved, and keep up the good work!

Click to expand...

Thanks.

The one thing I will admit though, is due to lots of sfx, you might struggle to play this with lowish ram. I played it on a laptop with 512 ram the other day, and the slowdown was noticable by midgame.

v0.96 uploaded

Terrain is straight rip off from Warcraft Maul Remade

Its a Maul...the only thing that changed is Tile...so who cares...even if its same Terrain tile its towers that count...not the Tile -_-

Using maybe 10 mins to make it look more unique would still be better than straight rip off

i guess but whats done is done lol

X.e.r.e.X said:

Using maybe 10 mins to make it look more unique would still be better than straight rip off

Click to expand...

I've credited the maker of Warcraft Maul Remade, and fixed many of the flaws that the terrain used to have (and still am). I just like the basic design and terrain of Warcraft Maul Remade so I kept it. IMO, Terrain is the least important part of a maul by far, as long as it works.

Exactly ^_^ why i dont take points off for Terrain in mauls.

Awesome maul!

So, I read the description and see...
Only the really known / popular animes?
Why no K-ON!, Rozen Maiden, DearS, Elfenlied, or something else?
No? Only Bleach etc. Well, I'll have a look if there will be some more races.

Good maul, I just wanna say that when is the next version gonna be?I've been waiting for 2 years perhaps just to wait for a new version.Is this map dead?