• Terrain: I think you did a good job with the terrain. I don't have much to say for improvements... I'd say more doodads would just make it look messy.
• Pathing: Nice wide open spaces, but not too wide. Makes it good for player interaction, can really get a nice battle.

I don't think I really have anything negative to say about the map. But there is one thing that stands out... The fact that you went out your way to create a quest tab to notify players that it's your map seems odd. Not sure if this is an accepted thing for melee maps... Would like to know though. All in all good map, it's something id consider playing again. Id give it a 3.5 rating if I could though.

Score: [3/5]

Its Ryan Boi said:

• Terrain: I think you did a good job with the terrain. I don't have much to say for improvements... I'd say more doodads would just make it look messy.
• Pathing: Nice wide open spaces, but not too wide. Makes it good for player interaction, can really get a nice battle.

I don't think I really have anything negative to say about the map. But there is one thing that stands out... The fact that you went out your way to create a quest tab to notify players that it's your map seems odd. Not sure if this is an accepted thing for melee maps... Would like to know though. All in all good map, it's something id consider playing again. Id give it a 3.5 rating if I could though.

Score: [3/5]

Click to expand...

Is not odd, and is allowed I did it in one of my melee maps (to credit Sauron tower model):
Mordor v 1.04


since is an informative tab, not a quest like the quests of the campaings.



this map can be downloaded (by anybody) and uploaded in a Chinese or a Rusian site (for example), and in that case maybe in the upload they won´t bother to say who did the map, in this way credits are inside the game too, and by that the original source.

I don´t do it, but when I use imported material, I create a quest giving credits to the models used. Since I like to have the full credits inside the game too.

by the way the map is great, I like the tile mix of Lordaeron winter and ICC.

see ya.

There are spaces between trees. Please fix them as they are pretty close to the main bases and may become spy zones.

Awaiting Update.


If you're not satisfied with the review and wish another opinion, contact the other reviewers or use the staff contact:
Paillan
twojstaryjakcie
Daffa the Mage
https://www.hiveworkshop.com/forums/staff-contact.692/

Edited Trees

The Panda said:

Edited Trees

Click to expand...

Approved.