Gameplay & Entertainment:I don't play a lot of monolith, but the gameplay is almost the same. It's a fun co op melee map fighting in this case new creep races from the original monolith, also some new skins and models. The biggest problem with this is that it's to easy, the creep attacks always fail at the main bases, horribly. The battles end to the slaughter for the creeps if you are like me and block off escapes and trap enemies. My elapsed game time is 30 minutes 2 ai and 2 players, and I was taking my time. I know you can say that if I play with easy computers it would be harder, but with a full house of human players it's going to be done quick and easy, and they are gonna get rekt!. It seems to me that normal leveled ally AI will win in a 4v4, change this around. You shouldn't have to rely on computers to win, (and if you are bad you can change the difficulty of your allies). You might want to look at the total kills difference for the creeps.
Sadly there aren't any neutral passive buildings, I'm sure some will turn this down because of this. Creeps don't even have drops. People love their heroes.
Overall, the gameplay is quite fun, I like more fast paced melee. It's quality is average.
12/20
Terrain & Layout:Well, you can't really go wrong with blizzard tiles and height leveling. The layout is great and is visually pleasing, we cross the river and we're in immediately in enemy territory. Map shaped is balanced as well. I will give a higher score if you match the theme of the creep races because they now don't match the Ashenvale theme.
6/10
Doodads & Scenery:Compared to other blizzard maps, this one is actually emptier than 90% (probably a bad estimate) of the melee maps. Add some shrubs, fallen logs, rocks, mushrooms, maybe even some temples or structures.
5/10
Bugs & Consistency:> AI holds position in odd places
> Wrong icon
> Don't just keep the title as Monolith, perhaps Jevan's Monolith or custom monolith will do
4/5
Presentation:Your description is lacking a little, but you are clear on the main parts. Please add screenshots (cakemaster has a link above) and state whether the map is free to use, protected, or unprotected and needs permission.
3/5