River of Blood (V.5)

[Moderator]

08:57, 28th Jun 2011
-Kobas-:
Status: Rejected

 

[light bolt30]

Change map type to altered melee since you've edited some settings. This map feels like you've spammed goldmines in some bad places.

 

[The Olympus king]

I love just alerted and castel maps,so can you please put in description what races can I have in game!!??OK,I realy need that,I realy hate when I looking description and I can't find the races.Like,dude,please put it in description.

 

[Marcin013]

i love just alerted and castel maps,so can you please put in description what races can i have in game!!??ok,i realy need that,i realy hate when i looking description and i can't find the races.like,dude,please put it in description.

lol this normal melle

 

[The Olympus king]

lol this normal melle

I noticed it when I started playing.

 

[Eldubs]

Its altered, because theres some changes in items.

 

[drakexx]

Ok my review:

Pro points:
1.The terrain is really unique
2.It's almost same at both sides
3.Good balanced Shop,mine,netral creep locations

Neutral points:
1.When you playing only1 player at in 1 corner [where have to be 3 players] you are rushed by neutrals when you build kinda bigger base

Bad points:
1. Didint saw any bad thing in the map

Owerall ratting:
-> 5/5+vote for aprovall.

 

[MrStormyZ]

seeing the minimap I wasn't actually going to see it but, after seeing someone gave it a 5/5 I said let's have a look

the layout is unique true I see that you might had worked hard to get those things like a mirror there

,but All you actually did with the other parts is use the Square brush around with the trees
circle for the upper Goldmines, and used the noise brush everywhere else leaving the start points

add a few doodads make use of more than 2-3 tiles in one game screen area to make it look appealing, I can show you some of it if you want but you can simply open any of the melee maps that come with the game to see how and where they are placed to look good

for now I won't rate anything until updated.

 

[Nagir]

add some screenshots

EDIT: I agree with MrStormyZ, add some doodads, and the main bases seem somewhat small, at least the one in the upper left corner.

 

[FriendlyHost]

Improve the description.

 

[Super-Sheep]

Seriously why are people who never played Melee rating maps like these with 5/5...

 

[Eldubs]

Improve the description.

Thats not a reason to rate this map 1/5

Seriously why are people who never played Melee rating maps like these with 5/5...

Only one person rated 5/5 and he plays melee maps pretty much.

 

[Ironside]

Ok my review:

Pro points:
1.The terrain is really unique
2.It's almost same at both sides
3.Good balanced Shop,mine,netral creep locations

Neutral points:
1.When you playing only1 player at in 1 corner [where have to be 3 players] you are rushed by neutrals when you build kinda bigger base

Bad points:
1. Didint saw any bad thing in the map

Owerall ratting:
-> 5/5+vote for aprovall.

Review Marked, I give it 4/5 though.


Rating: 4/5
Vote for: Approved

 

[-Kobas-]

Map has just 2 many errors.
Terrain is really bad.
Gold mines have up to 40.000 gold and some are placed next to each other.
Status: Rejected