Murky Water (Melee)

[Moderator]

Vengeancekael -
Date: 2012/May/16 18:26:01

Reasons:
Other:
Check out the tutorials section: Tutorials
Check out the Map Development Section: Map Development Section
Check out the World Editor Help Zone (Trigger issues, object editor, overall WE issues): WE Help Zone

Comment: [Approved]
Pretty neat looking melee map, the environment's very pretty and filled, the layout is symmetric, it follows the basic melee rules and I like the idea of having a bonus goldmine right behind your starting point, allowing for fast upgrading and a faster endgame with big army battles.
Admin Contact - Resource Moderation - Rules

 

[sonofjay]

I'll check this right away.

REVIEW:

BAD:

• I have no serious complaints on this one, the only thing that I think is bad is the trees are somewhat far on the starting point, this is a small disadvantage for the human, orc and undead. But this is not a big issue.

GOOD:

• Amazing terrain, well made, the layout is perfectly balance, also got some wild animals good use of height tools, good tile variation and no blizz cliffs.
• Hostile creeps are balance and place perfectly.
• Good drops for the hostile creeps.
• Balance placement of neutral buildings.
• Tavern is not guarded.
• Enough resources for each player

Suggestion:

• What can I suggest? Maybe add some flowers on some empty spaces.

MY RATING: 5/5 and +rep

MY NOTES:
One of the best melee map that I've seen so far, classic melee I love it, you prove to me that you're are one of the best on our group. keep up the good work.

If you got some questions regarding on my review please contact me.

 

[Ken-E]

If anyone is looking up at this map, please do visit its dedicated altered melee project by Kam.
(4)BtTaradise Shoals
Also, I have attach a post production of the BtT version, it only has a bit tweaking on the middle the copy was used for the BtT map. Also, I reckon someone might use it or whatever, it also serves as a proof WiP if any.

 

[Map Designer]

I must look at this sometime!

 

[deepstrasz]

I suggest the heavy reduction of the resource of the Gold Mine nearest to the players.
Check to see if all neutral hostile units start with 100% mana.
The start location Gold Mine is undefended when a player does not spawn there.