Modeling Competiton #7 POLL

Modeling Competition #7 Poll

Modeling Competition #7 has come to a close, now we must vote for the best Siege Weapon!

Our fierce combatants are:

• Lord_T with his Gruntapult
• Skrab with his Battle Machine
• Mechanical Man with his Flame Tank
• Kofi_Banan with his Peon Pong Tank
• Werewulf with her SkullSiege
• PyramidHe@d with his Dog of War

Let the voting begin!

Notes:

1. Mechanical Man: If you wish to change to your other submission, PM me.
2. Watch for the reviews, as sometime within the next week, I will post my own judgments!

--donut3.5--

I voted peon pong tank though the choice was hard between the Dog of war.
The skull siege is smoothly animated but too messy (the neck isn't weld) and messy UV.
It miss supa and madsen submission?

Originally Posted by Steel_Stallion

but its a joke (in the literal sense) i mean, i cant find much use for it, except for a humor map. I cant put it in an actual war map, while the other models i can.

It can be used as a Catapult :P You dont have to call it Peon Pong Tank, Peon Catapult would fit it too i think.

Meh, I should have submitted hellbore instead

And is a flame cannon, not flame tank.

Voted for Kofi's as it is most original idea, and funny made.

Werewulfs and Lord-T I wondered about also.

Originally Posted by Steel_Stallion

...the battle machine is a cool concept but you cant see any machinery parts, so it doesnt feel real, its a walking tree with a mace and a badly done bow (sorry) and the animations are slow and not as smooth as i would have hoped...

i didn't have time to finish the model till the end of competition

almost all of these, really, just seem rather amateur and childish xD

Scrab's FTW! Meow.

Originally Posted by SuPa-

almost all of these, really, just seem rather amateur and childish xD

At least we finished them. Often quantity (still with decent quality) is more important than quality in gaming. Wc3 models also seem rather amateur and childish anyways.

Originally Posted by SuPa-

almost all of these, really, just seem rather amateur and childish xD

Wich kinda fits wc.

I cant dicide wich to vote... =S

Originally Posted by SuPa-

almost all of these, really, just seem rather amateur and childish xD

If so, why you didnt show us profesional model with quality we should go for. Blame Blizzard for Wc3 Theme, all works fits this theme well in my opinion.

my vote goes to PyramidHe@d´s Dog of War because I really like the concept and its animations are nice

Originally Posted by Kofi_Banan

If so, why you didnt show us profesional model with quality we should go for. Blame Blizzard for Wc3 Theme, all works fits this theme well in my opinion.

Well, you shouldn't blame Blizzard for anything. This competition wasn't WC3 themed necessarily, and at least WC3 models have good animations, unlike yours which are like all your others, a bare minimum that just stands there 3/4 of the time. If you're going to act like a baby that just further reflects upon you and your similarity to your not-even-half-baked models -_- You even voted for yourself which is above all, pathetic and bad sportsmanship

Originally Posted by SuPa-

Well, you shouldn't blame Blizzard for anything.

I did not. Remind me if i did.

Originally Posted by SuPa-

This competition wasn't WC3 themed necessarily,

It wasnt prohibited too.

Originally Posted by SuPa-

and at least WC3 models have good animations, unlike yours which are like all your others, a bare minimum that just stands there 3/4 of the time.

Yes, i agree. But Im modeling for fun. As soon as i will find need for better anims i will do it. Im modeling for noone else than me.

Originally Posted by SuPa-

If you're going to act like a baby that just further reflects upon you and your similarity to your not-even-half-baked models -_-

Oh come on who is acting like a baby.

Originally Posted by SuPa-

You even voted for yourself which is above all, pathetic and bad sportsmanship

-Ever heard of president voting for his opponent in election?
-Show me a rule that i broke.


Firstly i didnt want to react after your ''almost all of these, really, just seem rather amateur and childish xD'' In my opinion your post was completly not neccesary, you definetly could keep it for yourself. Maybe my reply wasnt necessary too and it was a mistake, but your acting ''im champion thos are shyt to me, look im best'' annoyed me too much. Maybe you are skilled both in texturing and modeling. I Cant say anything bad about quality of your works. (Altough i see that you are stock in Purple Allien Futuristic Theme even for the contest) . But I cant stand treating others like some nameless modeling creatures.You are not uber super modeler tough. This is not Contest for Profesional 3d dudes, indeed it is Amateur Contest. Animated and skinned box could enter the contest too. Understand that its not Profesional Modeling Website.
I hate arrogant self centered behaving, thats why i had to reply.

Originally Posted by SuPa-

Well, you shouldn't blame Blizzard for anything. This competition wasn't WC3 themed necessarily, and at least WC3 models have good animations, unlike yours which are like all your others, a bare minimum that just stands there 3/4 of the time. If you're going to act like a baby that just further reflects upon you and your similarity to your not-even-half-baked models -_- You even voted for yourself which is above all, pathetic and bad sportsmanship

Grow up supamaking such a big deal about perfectly fine model..

Im hesitating on who to vote, because I havnt tested ingame, but the ping-pong luancher seems best from screenshots...